Published 2026-11-16 · Last updated 2026-11-16
Nobody outside OpenAI knows the exact formula, and OpenAI says ChatGPT ranks results using multiple factors and that placement is not guaranteed. What you can see is what the answer tells you it read. When I asked ChatGPT where to practice at a range near Salem, New Hampshire, it named one top pick and gave its reason: it was one of the closest places it could verify, and it quoted details the business had published about itself. Optimus Business Solutions, a web design and AI systems company in Salem, explains what that answer showed, what the research says about how AI picks a local business, and what an owner can check so the facts AI finds are complete and the same everywhere.
What did ChatGPT show me when I asked for a local business?
I'm an Army veteran and I love to shoot. My cousin and I have been meaning to get to the range together, so on my way to the gym I asked ChatGPT one question: where is the closest range to me in Salem, where I can practice regularly, bring a friend and rent something to try? I haven't been to any of the places it named, and none of them are clients of ours. This is not a review. It is a look at how the choice got made.

It did not give me ten links. It gave me one business first, with a little green badge that said My top pick, then two others, a map with star pins, photos and a short table. Then it told me why: one of the closest public indoor ranges it could verify, with a good selection of rentals. Underneath, it quoted the rental list the business publishes on its own website, with a small source chip, and the memberships its business listing advertises.
| What the answer showed | What it tells an owner |
|---|---|
| One business marked My top pick | The customer may see one name first, not a page of links |
| "One of the closest ... I could verify" | The answer leaned on facts it could check |
| Details quoted from the business's own website, with a source chip | Your website is one of the places it reads |
| A map with three star pins, the top pick lowest on my screen | Stars were not the only thing on the table |
| A line telling me to verify the membership costs before signing up | Even the top pick came with a reason to double-check |
Do star ratings decide which business ChatGPT recommends?
Not on their own, at least not on my screen. The map pins read 3.8 for the top pick, and 4.0 and 4.3 for the other two. Reviews still matter, and I tell every client that. But in this answer, the highest stars did not get the badge, and the reason ChatGPT gave me was what it could verify.
Outside research points the same way, with care. One study of 10,000 local businesses by Insites found the number of reviews tracked AI recommendations more closely than the star rating, which was a comparatively weak predictor. That is a correlation from one vendor, not a formula. And one BrightLocal study of about 200,000 local searches found that when the same question was asked again, ChatGPT's lists overlapped only about 23 percent. So no single screenshot proves a rule, mine included. What it shows is that the answer is built from what the AI can find and check at that moment.
Where does ChatGPT get its local business information?
OpenAI says ChatGPT gets local business information from trusted third-party providers, and it does not name them. It also says that claiming a business profile does not guarantee higher placement. In my answer, the map inside the response was Apple Maps, and the details it quoted came from the business's own website and its business listing.
That is why a business's footprint is bigger than its website. The same facts about you live on your site, Google, Apple, Yelp, Bing and the professional platforms in your trade. BrightLocal's 2026 consumer survey found Apple Maps use for reading reviews nearly doubled, from 14 percent to 27 percent. When did you last open your Apple listing?
Why did the top pick still come with a warning?
This is the part most owners will miss. Even after picking the business, ChatGPT told me to verify the membership costs directly before signing up, because, in its words, the range's published walk-in rates differ across sources. So I checked the range's own website, and its rates matched what ChatGPT had shown me. The AI still told me to double-check.
AI answers can be wrong or out of date, and OpenAI says search results and citations can be incomplete or incorrect. Now picture your own business. Your hours on Google say one thing, your website says another, and an old directory says a third. A person might shrug that off. An AI may pass the doubt straight to your customer, in writing, right under your name.
How many customers ask AI to find a local business?
More every month. BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults found 45 percent had used ChatGPT or similar tools for local recommendations, up from 6 percent a year earlier, which made AI the third most popular source of business recommendations. SOCi's 2026 survey, as reported in November, found 52 percent had used an AI tool to find a local business in the last 30 days, and 81 percent said they verify an AI recommendation first. Both are what people said in a survey, not tracked behavior, but the direction is clear.
Flip my question around. Your customer asks: who is the best plumber near me who can come out Saturday? Which roofer near me does free estimates? If the answer is one top pick and a couple of others, you want the AI to have every true fact it needs about you, and nothing that makes it hedge.
What can a business owner check this week?
- Ask ChatGPT the question your best customer would ask, word for word, with your town in it, and read what it says about you and what it tells the customer to double-check
- Open your Google, Apple, Yelp and Bing listings side by side and make the hours, services, service area and phone number the same on all four
- Make sure your website states your services, your area and your hours in plain words on the page, not only inside a picture
- Look for an old directory or an old page that still carries last year's hours or rates, and update it or take it down
- Ask happy customers for reviews steadily, because the number of reviews is one of the things outside studies keep finding
Read our guide to custom websites and Google's AI answers
What does AI search optimization actually do?
That is exactly what I do. I optimize a business's digital footprint so AI has what it needs to select it. Nobody can promise a pick, and OpenAI says so itself. What we can do is make sure every fact the AI checks is there and true: a custom-coded website that states your services, your area and your hours in plain words a machine can read, and your professional platforms, Google, Apple, Yelp, Bing and the rest, all telling the same true story.
This is the next generation of search I always talk about with my clients. It is preparing for the future instead of settling for outdated technology, and for a business owner that is one of the most important decisions you will ever make: investing in your business's longevity.
If you want to know what AI can verify about your business, send us a message, leave a comment on any of our posts, or fill out the form on our website, and we will set up a 15-minute call. On the call, Anthony asks ChatGPT the question your customer would ask about your business and shows you what it can and can't verify. As for me, I'm taking my cousin to the range.
Common questions
How does ChatGPT decide which business to recommend?
Nobody outside OpenAI knows the exact formula. OpenAI says ChatGPT ranks results using multiple factors and that placement is not guaranteed. In the answer I received, its stated reason for the top pick was that it was one of the closest places it could verify, and it quoted details the business published itself.
Does the highest star rating always win in ChatGPT?
No. On my screen, the top pick had a 3.8 pin while the other two had 4.0 and 4.3. One study by Insites found review count tracked AI recommendations more closely than the rating. Reviews still matter, but they are not the only thing an AI looks at.
Where does ChatGPT get information about local businesses?
OpenAI says it uses trusted third-party providers and does not name them. In my answer, the map was Apple Maps and the details came from the business's own website and its business listing.
Can anyone guarantee ChatGPT will recommend my business?
No. OpenAI says placement is not guaranteed, and claiming a business profile does not guarantee higher placement. What you can control is that the facts AI finds about you are complete, current and the same everywhere.
How many people use AI to find local businesses?
BrightLocal's 2026 survey found 45 percent of US adults had used ChatGPT or similar tools for local recommendations, up from 6 percent a year earlier. These are survey answers, not tracked behavior.
Submit an inquiry about what AI can verify about your business
